Skip to content

How long fresh home-grown mushrooms last

How many days fresh mushrooms keep in the fridge, the signs they are past it, and what to do when you can't eat a harvest in time.

Last checked 18 November 2026

Plan to eat fresh mushrooms within a few days. Two sources give different ceilings. Use your eyes as well as the calendar.

The numbers on offer

Penn State Extension suggests a paper bag in the fridge for up to 3 days.1

An Australian magazine, quoting a food scientist, says mushrooms stored in a paper bag in the fridge can last up to a week. It then adds that the current advice is to consume them in under a week.2

Those two figures don't match. You can read them as a range: a few days is the cautious end, and a week is the outer edge. Plan around the short end.

Type matters

The magazine warns that enoki and oyster types can go slimy sooner than button mushrooms, sometimes within 2-3 days in plastic.2 That's a plastic example, not a paper one, so don't treat it as a promise for either container.

If you grow more than one kind, eat the delicate ones first.

Signs they are past it

The food scientist's list is short and clear. Mushrooms that become slimy, smell sour or develop dark wet patches should not be eaten. Mould growth is also a clear sign of spoilage.2

Penn State adds a wider rule for produce. Bin anything bruised, damaged or contaminated.1

A daily checkOpen the bagLook for dark wet patchesSmell for a sour noteBin or cook
Look, smell and touch before you cook.

A quick check before cooking

  • Look: any dark, wet-looking patches?
  • Smell: does it have a sour note?
  • Touch: is the surface slimy rather than just cool?
  • Look closely for fuzz or mould anywhere on the cap or stem.

If the answer to any of these is yes, the sources say not to eat them.2 Mouldy mushrooms go in the bin. Don't cut the bad part off and keep the rest.

Sort once, not daily

Open the bag, check it, and close it again. If one mushroom has turned, take it out and look hard at its neighbours.

When you can't eat them in time

A big flush often arrives all at once. Penn State's guide notes there are several ways to preserve mushrooms for future use.1 On this site, the first is drying at home, and the heat and timing are in the dehydrator guide.

Dry them while they're still firm. Drying won't rescue mushrooms that are already slimy or mouldy. Those belong in the bin, not in the dehydrator.

Keeping your own notes

Because the sources differ, a short note on the bag helps. Write the harvest date on it. Over a few harvests you'll see how your own variety behaves in your own fridge, which no general guide can tell you. That's your record, not a claim this site can back up.

For the storage routine, see the fridge routine. For the container choice, see paper bag, box or plastic.

Sources used

  1. Preparing and Preserving Mushrooms, Penn State Extension
  2. Why you should never buy mushrooms in plastic containers, Better Homes & Gardens Australia