Storing fresh home-grown mushrooms in the fridge
How to keep freshly picked home-grown mushrooms from going slimy: a paper bag, the right fridge spot, and when to wash them.
Put freshly picked mushrooms in a paper bag and keep the bag in the fridge. That's the short answer. The sources agree on it. The rest of this page gives the reasoning, so you can adjust the routine to your own harvest and fridge.
Why paper beats plastic
Penn State Extension says loose mushrooms can dry out when they aren't in a paper bag. It also says moisture can collect on mushrooms in a plastic bag and spoil them.1
A food scientist quoted by an Australian magazine explains the other half. Mushrooms hold a lot of water and give some of it off. Paper takes up excess moisture and lets air move around the mushrooms, so the surface stays drier.2
A dry surface is the goal, and every step below aims at it.
Pick the right spot in the fridge
Use the main compartment of the fridge, not the crisper drawer. The same article says a crisper is designed to trap humidity, and that's not what mushrooms want.2
So the drawer many people use for vegetables isn't the place for them.
Hold off on washing
Don't wash mushrooms before you store them. The article says moisture speeds up spoilage, and it suggests washing just before cooking.2
If your mushrooms came off the block clean, you have nothing to do until the pan. If they're dirty, clean them when you're ready to cook, not the night before.
A simple routine
- Harvest the mushrooms and sort out any that are bruised or damaged.1
- Put the good ones in a paper bag, loosely and not packed tight.
- Fold the top over and place the bag on a main shelf, away from the crisper.
- Keep the bag apart from raw meat, poultry, seafood and eggs, and from household chemicals.1
- Wash the mushrooms only when you're about to cook them.
Penn State's advice on bruised produce is blunt: throw it out if it shows signs of bruising, damage or contamination.1 A single damaged mushroom isn't worth risking the rest of the bag.
If your mushrooms are already in plastic
Sometimes a harvest ends up in a tub or a bag, or you've been given some. Move them. The magazine's advice is to transfer plastic-wrapped mushrooms to a paper bag as soon as you get home.2 Wrapping them in a paper towel is its other suggestion.2
Delicate types need more care
Not every mushroom ages at the same pace. The article names enoki and oyster mushrooms as delicate types that can turn slimy faster than button mushrooms.2 If you grow oysters, plan to eat them first.
The bag doesn't stop the clock. Fresh mushrooms are a short-term food. Days and warning signs are on the shelf life page. Picked more than you can eat? Drying is the next option here. For bags, boxes and tubs, see the container comparison.
Sources used
- Preparing and Preserving Mushrooms, Penn State Extension
- Why you should never buy mushrooms in plastic containers, Better Homes & Gardens Australia