Skip to content

Paper bag, box or plastic: which container suits fresh mushrooms

Compare paper bags, paper towels, the original container and plastic for fresh mushrooms, and why the wrapping changes how long they stay firm.

Last checked 18 November 2026

Paper wins for fresh mushrooms. The reason is water. A container that traps moisture is the wrong one, and one that lets mushrooms dry out is nearly as bad.

What each container does

Mushrooms hold a lot of water. An Australian magazine quotes a food scientist who says that when they sit in plastic, moisture is trapped and can't escape because plastic doesn't allow airflow.1 The same scientist says the plastic container essentially traps mushrooms in their own condensation.1

Penn State Extension describes the two failures in one line. Loose mushrooms stored outside a paper bag can dry out. Mushrooms in a plastic bag can collect moisture, which can spoil them.2

So you're steering between two faults: too dry and too wet.

Containers side by side

Container What the sources say
Paper bag Recommended by Penn State Extension for the fridge.2 The food scientist calls paper breathable.1
Paper towel wrap The magazine says wrapping mushrooms in a paper towel also works.1
Original container Penn State Extension lists it as an option for mushrooms that came packed.2
Plastic bag Moisture can collect on the mushrooms and spoil them.2
Sealed plastic tub Traps mushrooms in their own condensation, per the food scientist.1

Why plastic goes wrong

The scientist's explanation is about air as well as water. Plastic doesn't let anything breathe, so the space inside becomes humid and low in oxygen. Low oxygen and high moisture speed up the breakdown, browning and bacterial growth that lead to sliminess.1

You don't need to remember the chemistry. If you see beads of water inside a bag or tub, the container is working against you.

Choosing a paper bag

You aren't buying anything fancy here, and there's no model to compare. Look at a few plain things before you use one.

  • Is it clean and dry? A damp bag defeats the point.
  • Is it big enough that the mushrooms aren't squashed?
  • Does it fold shut loosely, rather than sealing?
  • Does it have any chemical smell or leftover contents?

None of these checks come from a maker's spec, so treat them as common sense rather than a standard.

A paper towel as a back-up

If you haven't got a bag, the magazine says a paper towel wrap also works.1 A towel sitting against wet mushrooms will soak up water and go limp itself. Check it and replace it if it's wet. The article's own advice is to change the towel daily.1

Containers you already have

A home grower often harvests straight into a tub or a basket. That's fine for the walk from the grow area to the kitchen. The bag matters for the hours and days afterwards.

  • Basket or open tray: good for carrying, but loose mushrooms can dry out.2
  • Lidded plastic box: avoid for storage, since moisture can't leave.1
  • Cardboard box: not covered by either source, so this site makes no claim about it.
Choosing a containerCheck the mushrooms are dryChoose a breathable containerFold or loosely close itKeep it on a main shelf
Work from the wettest problem to the driest answer.

The fridge shelf and washing are covered in storing fresh home-grown mushrooms. To learn how many days a bagged harvest keeps, read how long fresh mushrooms last.

Sources used

  1. Why you should never buy mushrooms in plastic containers, Better Homes & Gardens Australia
  2. Preparing and Preserving Mushrooms, Penn State Extension